Ditch the Carrier. Own the Benefit Plan.

How Community Health Models Put Employers In Control

If you want to provide health insurance for your employees, you need to work with an insurance  carrier, or a broker who is appointed through an insurance carrier, right?

Wrong! There’s actually an alternative. A community health plan connects employers and their teams with hospitals and providers to control costs and remove barriers to care.

An End to the Annual Headache

The McKinsey 2024 Employer Health Benefits survey found that roughly two in three employers want to switch health insurance carriers sometime during the next four years.

Many employers are dissatisfied with their current coverage. Every year, they face price hikes and plan changes that push employer budgets to the breaking point and negatively impact employee engagement. The annual open enrollment becomes a stressful period, when employers and employees are forced to select the plan that sucks the least.

Many employers are looking for alternatives. Some simply look for another carrier, even though all carriers use the same basic health insurance model, in which the carrier acts as a middleman between employers and providers, often with strict networks and pre-authorization requirements. Switching carriers may provide some modest advantages, but it’s unlikely to be revolutionary.

Other employers are interested in taking more drastic steps. For example, according to AP News, some employers are adopting Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangements (ICHRAs) to give workers cash so they can buy a health plan on their own. While this may seem easier for the employer, who no longer has to compare plans, it’s really just passing the buck to workers, who still have to buy a terrible plan, usually on the marketplace, using the traditional carrier model.

A community health plan built with direct contracts is completely different. This solution bypasses the carrier model entirely, disrupting the status quo to provide meaningful improvement.

How Does Direct Contracting Work?

In the community health plan model, employers contract directly with hospitals and providers in their communities. The carrier is removed from the equation, and the employer becomes the payer. This arrangement provides meaningful advantages for all the players involved:

  • Employers experience substantial savings. The average first year premium savings for employers is 24%, and the average annual increase to plans over three years is less than 1.9%, creating a much more sustainable and predictable healthcare model.
  • Healthcare providers are freed from carrier red tape. According to the American Hospital Association (AHA), 80% of physicians say health insurance practices affect their ability to practice medicine. With direct contracting, physicians can engage with patients without worrying about carrier interference. They can also receive direct feedback from the purchasers – the employers – in order to form partnerships that deliver results.
  • Employees save money and enjoy higher quality benefits. Employees contribute less out of their paychecks and enjoy very low, or in some cases, no deductibles, with low out-of-pocket costs. The AHA says 62% of patients have experienced delayed medical care due to their insurance provider in the last two years. With a direct contracting arrangement, this is no longer a problem.

A Long-Term Solution

Health insurance costs keep rising, but premiums and out-of-pocket costs can only go so high before care becomes unaffordable. Every year, employers and their workers go through the same old song and dance with no real relief. It’s time to change this.

The problems in the current healthcare system require more than a quick Band-Aid solution. Community health plans that use direct contracting with providers and health systems offer a complete break from the status quo.

Are you fed up with the carrier model of healthcare? Watch this video from my colleague, Garrett Weldon to learn more.

Key Takeaways

  • Employers Are Frustrated With the Traditional Carrier Model
  • Switching Carriers Rarely Solves the Real Problem
  • Direct Contracting Removes the Insurance Middleman
  • The Model Creates Financial Benefits for Employers and Employees
  • Providers Gain More Freedom to Deliver Care

Related Posts

The Hidden Cost of Bad Benefits

What Would $500,000 Mean for Your Company? Many employers don’t realize how much bad benefits quietly drain from their business. When Wada Farms switched to a direct health plan, the company saved nearly $500,000 over four years. For a family-owned business, this savings was huge. It represented meaningful capital that

Direct Contracting Done Right: How Employers & Hospitals Win Together

What if employers and hospitals stopped negotiating against each other? In this episode of the Dysrupt Healthcare Podcast, Lester J. Morales sits down with Doug Hetherington, founder of Health to Business, to talk about a different approach to healthcare purchasing one rooted in transparency, partnership, and long-term alignment. This isn’t

2026 Outlook: Why Employers Settle for the Health Plan that Sucks the Least

If your company’s last employee benefits renewal involved choosing the option that sucks the least, you’re not alone. While the Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker reports that small group insurers proposed an average premium increase of 11% for the 2026 plan year, many employers experienced increases that were much steeper than