New Plan, Same Habits: Why Benefits Communication Can’t Stop After Open Enrollment

You changed your company’s health plan. Next comes the hard part: changing behavior.

When employers switch to better health plans, they expect better results. Sometimes there’s a disconnect. You may be offering better primary care access, more telehealth options, new navigation resources and other services that make health care both more convenient and more affordable, but these changes won’t automatically result in better experiences or lower costs if employees keep falling into the same old habits. To see real improvement, you need effective year-round benefits communication that supports employee benefits engagement and helps employees make the most of their new options.

Employees Bring Last Year’s Habits Into This Year’s Plan

People tend to develop health care routines. They see the same doctor, use the same pharmacy and go to the same urgent care or ER when they can’t get a regular appointment.

A new plan doesn’t automatically erase those habits, even if you’re offering better alternatives and additional services.

This can be a big problem for employers that have rolled out major changes. If you invest in improvements like direct partnerships, telehealth programs and care navigation services, you want employees to use them, and a low utilization rate can undermine your benefits strategy.

Employees can suffer, too. They may end up paying higher out-of-pocket costs or dealing with long appointment wait times because they’re not maximizing their benefits.

But if employees don’t understand what’s different, they’ll continue behaving as though nothing has changed.

Information Overload Won’t Change Behavior

During open enrollment, employees are often overloaded with information about their benefits. Some of the information may help them make good coverage selections, but it won’t necessarily help them use their coverage in the new year.

A detailed explanation of urgent care alternatives in November may mean little to an employee who doesn’t get sick until March. A presentation about prescription resources won’t necessarily be remembered when a physician prescribes a new medication six months later.

Employers can help employees access the information they need when they need it by sharing bite-size benefits communications throughout the year. Instead of dumping a 30-page benefits guide, communicate one useful thing at a time, and do it over a period of months.

For example, in January, you can focus benefits education on where to go for primary care. In February, you can list options for same-day care. In March, you can explain where to fill prescriptions. In summer, you can show options for care while traveling. In fall, you can focus on preventive care.

You can create a calendar ahead of time that covers seasonal issues, but it’s also good to leave room for education based on your plan data and employee feedback. For example, if employee feedback indicates concerns about prescription costs, provide information on where to fill prescriptions and generic versus brand-name costs.

Make the Better Choice Easy to Act On

Instead of telling employees what services are available, tell them how they can use their benefits.

For example:

  • Instead of telling your employees that your plan includes a direct provider partnership, tell them which primary care providers they can use for the lowest out-of-pocket costs.
  • Instead of telling them that they have telehealth benefits, explain how they can make a telehealth appointment if they have an infection or other minor health issue that requires timely care.
  • Instead of telling them they have access to care navigation services, give them the number to call if they need help finding a specialist.

Give Employees a Reason to Change

Health care is a very personal matter, and your employees won’t necessarily change their habits just because you tell them it will save the plan money. If you want your employees to switch to a preferred provider or use a new resource, you have to show them how doing so will benefit them.

Depending on the plan design and benefit options, this might mean:

  • Lower out-of-pocket costs
  • Easier appointments
  • More convenient care
  • Local providers
  • Help navigating the system
  • Less confusion

Employee Benefits Engagement Drives Plan Performance

Plan design is only one factor that contributes to plan performance. Another is whether employees understand their options and use the plan as intended.

You can negotiate a strong provider arrangement, introduce valuable services and design thoughtful incentives, but these investments only deliver their full value when your employees understand their options and use them. This means that employee engagement is an essential part of successful health plan implementation.

This is especially important for employers using innovative ways to provide high-quality care, such as direct provider partnerships. Your workers may not understand how a direct partnership works or what it means for them. Strong communication can help the transition go smoothly and prevent confusion or misunderstandings.

When Open Enrollment Ends, Benefits Engagement Shouldn’t

Open enrollment has an end date. Employee health care needs don’t.

Instead of concentrating benefits communication into a few hectic weeks each fall, employers can use year-round communication to help employees understand their options when those options actually matter. Consistent, timely education can help turn a well-designed health plan into one employees understand, use and value.

Want to see how real employers are putting this approach into practice with direct partnership plans? Check out these case studies.

Key-Takeaways

  • New Plans Don’t Change Old Habits: Employees need guidance to take advantage of better benefits.
  • Communicate Year-Round: Benefits education shouldn’t stop after open enrollment.
  • Keep Messaging Simple: Share timely, bite-sized information instead of overwhelming employees.
  • Make Benefits Easy to Use: Provide actionable guidance and highlight personal savings and convenience.
  • Engagement Drives Results: Employees who understand and use their benefits help improve health plan performance.

Related Posts

Your Health Plan Changed. Do Your Employees Know How to Use It?

Open enrollment may be wrapping up, but successful implementation is just beginning. Employers spend months evaluating costs, networks, benefits and vendors. By the time open enrollment ends, they may be ready to move on. For employees, the experience is very different. They may not hear anything about plan changes until

ER, Urgent Care or Primary Care? Help Employees Choose the Right Care Setting

Employee engagement shouldn’t end with enrollment. Employers devote significant attention to designing health plans around cost, quality and access. But once the plan is in employees’ hands, individual decisions about where to receive care can shape both the employee experience and plan spending. By helping employees identify appropriate care options,

The First 90 Days of a New Health Plan: What Employers Should Monitor

Quoting is not a solution, but rather masks the underlying problems. January 1 isn’t the finish line. It’s the time to get to work. Employers spend months selecting a health plan and orchestrating open enrollment. Once the new plan goes into effect, it can be tempting to consider the work