The First 90 Days of a New Health Plan: What Employers Should Monitor

Quoting is not a solution, but rather masks the underlying problems. January 1 isn’t the finish line. It’s the time to get to work.

Employers spend months selecting a health plan and orchestrating open enrollment. Once the new plan goes into effect, it can be tempting to consider the work done until the next renewal cycle. But your work isn’t done yet. The first 90 days of health plan performance can provide insight into whether a plan is working as intended, where employees are struggling and what additional support employers may need to provide.

What Employers Can Learn in the First 90 Days

In the weeks and months following January 1, employees are using their new ID cards for the first time, finding providers, scheduling appointments and filling prescriptions. As they try to use their coverage, questions and problems may emerge. Some of these issues may expose gaps in plan communication, access or implementation. For example, if employees are struggling to schedule appointments, is it because they’re having trouble identifying in-network providers, or because those providers aren’t offering appointments within a reasonable amount of time?

At the same time, early utilization data may begin to reveal whether employees are using the plan as intended. For example, if you’ve offered telehealth as a convenient, lower-cost care alternative, are employees using it, or are they still relying on emergency and urgent care settings? And if utilization is not as expected, does the problem stem from a lack of benefits communication or a mismatch between benefits and needs?

Don’t wait until your next renewal to ask whether the plan is working. The sooner you identify problems, the sooner you can fix them.

Start With the Questions Employees Are Asking

Employee questions can help you uncover gaps in your plan communications, especially if the same questions keep coming up. For example, if employees keep asking whether a doctor is covered, they may be having trouble accessing or using the provider directory.

To understand where additional support may be needed, track recurring questions, such as:

  • Is my doctor covered?
  • Where is my ID card?
  • Why didn’t my prescription go through?
  • Where do I go for urgent care?
  • How do I access telehealth?
  • Who do I call about this bill?
  • How do I find a specialist?
  • How does this new benefit work?

Taken together, these questions can provide an early indication of whether employees understand and can effectively use the benefits the organization is paying for.

Monitor Care Transitions

For employees with ongoing health needs, plan switches or changes to an existing plan can be particularly disruptive. It can be helpful to look for patterns within your plan.

Assess aggregate data to determine how employees with chronic conditions, scheduled procedures, pregnancy, or behavioral health care needs are faring. Do they need to switch doctors or facilities? Do they have to go through prior authorization requirements again? Are they able to get the care they need? If problems are common, investigate the underlying cause so you can start looking for solutions.

Compare Actual Utilization With Expectations

A well-designed plan can help point employees toward appropriate, high-value care. But, what happens in real life doesn’t always match the design. When it doesn’t, your plan may not perform as well as you hoped.

During the first 90 days, utilization data can start to reveal whether your employees are using the plan the way you assumed they would. For example, are employees using the plan’s preferred providers, and have they established primary care? Are they choosing telehealth when appropriate? Are they making use of navigation services?

If there is a disconnect, the next step is to ask why. Maybe employees don’t understand their options. Maybe they can’t access care. Maybe the process is cumbersome. Or maybe the plan design does not provide enough incentive to encourage different care choices.

Don’t Overlook the Employee Experience

Claims data tells you what happened. Employee feedback can help you understand why.

Look to HR inquiries, complaints, navigation requests, billing disputes and other sources of employee feedback to get a feel for the employee experience. The 90-day mark can also be a good time to conduct a confidential survey.

Use the First 90 Days to Make Small Course Corrections

Some of the information you gather during the first 90 days may help inform your next renewal and open enrollment seasons. In the meantime, you can make small course corrections to address gaps that you uncover.

Early interventions might include:

  • Clarifying communications
  • Reminding employees about underused resources
  • Improving instructions for finding providers
  • Promoting navigation resources
  • Educating employees about preferred providers
  • Correcting misconceptions or misunderstandings
  • Targeting communications around recurring questions

Treat Your Health Plan as an Ongoing Management Priority

A health plan is too important to put on autopilot. By monitoring performance throughout the year, employers can identify emerging issues earlier, improve the employee experience and make more informed decisions about cost, access and plan design.

This is especially true for self-funded employers, who often have greater visibility into plan performance and more opportunities to respond to emerging trends. The first 90 days provide an early opportunity to listen, learn and adjust.

The insights employers gain during those first 90 days can also reveal opportunities to improve access to care and better align care with workforce needs. Direct provider partnerships offer one way to connect plan design, local access and utilization more closely. Learn how the direct model can support a responsive health plan.

Key Takeaways

  • Monitor Early Performance: The first 90 days can reveal health plan issues before they become bigger problems.
  • Listen to Employees: Recurring questions and feedback can uncover gaps in communication and benefits access.
  • Track Care Transitions: Ensure employees with ongoing health needs can access care without unnecessary disruptions.
  • Evaluate Plan Utilization: Compare actual usage with expectations to identify underused benefits and barriers to care.
  • Make Early Adjustments: Use initial insights to improve communication, employee experiences and overall plan performance.

Related Posts

Your Health Plan Changed. Do Your Employees Know How to Use It?

Open enrollment may be wrapping up, but successful implementation is just beginning. Employers spend months evaluating costs, networks, benefits and vendors. By the time open enrollment ends, they may be ready to move on. For employees, the experience is very different. They may not hear anything about plan changes until

New Plan, Same Habits: Why Benefits Communication Can’t Stop After Open Enrollment

You changed your company’s health plan. Next comes the hard part: changing behavior. When employers switch to better health plans, they expect better results. Sometimes there’s a disconnect. You may be offering better primary care access, more telehealth options, new navigation resources and other services that make health care both

ER, Urgent Care or Primary Care? Help Employees Choose the Right Care Setting

Employee engagement shouldn’t end with enrollment. Employers devote significant attention to designing health plans around cost, quality and access. But once the plan is in employees’ hands, individual decisions about where to receive care can shape both the employee experience and plan spending. By helping employees identify appropriate care options,